Angelina's Pizza - Olmsted Falls

Angelina's recently moved locations to Bagley Rd. They need to update their address on Yelp.

This was our first time picking up pizza from the new location. We ordered 2 large and a small cheesy breadsticks. I'm not sure what happened but we still have one pizza left? Maybe it was a miracle of the multiplying pizza? Or, the pizzas were large enough and filling enough to fill us up?

The cheese was my favorite part. The sauce is good too. The crust is very fresh, but doesn't seem to have any qualities to make it memorable.

My one main question about this restaurant is- what are 'fresh Italians'? Their logo advertises them as 'the fresh Italians'. I find that a bit strange and confusing. Is their family known for their strong grooming? So they smell fresh and clean? Are they know to be young- so their the new kids on the block? It would make more sense if it just said, 'fresh, Italian'. But when it says 'Italians', you're clearly indicating the people behind the food. I'll assume the owners are known for their strong grooming habits.

Strong grooming habits and good pizza equals a pizza place worth trying. It won't change your life, but it's a good place to get pizza tonight.

Biting into this gives me nostalgia. Not the kind of nostalgia you might think (insert Grandma throwing dough in the air round and round). Nostalgia meaning, is there a skee ball machine nearby? Perhaps a bunch of snotty nosed kids screaming everywhere loaded up on sugary soda.

I had higher hopes for this place as it had the best of the worst ratings near where I was. I'm so disappointed. The dough, tasteless, starting to get soggy, so I can't hold it. Tastes like $1 pizza. What one would expect at a kids party or a 7-11. The tomato sauce is sickly sweet, and don't get me started on the cheese. There's no way it came from a cow. The crust reminds of those papier-mâché breadsticks my mom had sitting in the faux bread basket as decoration that a high school buddy once devoured when he was high.

On the upside, they sure are fast delivering.

We liked the pizzas! The crust was crisp and the ground sausage was very tasty. The veggie pizza was excellent too. The shop was clean and the staff were friendly.

Stopped in twice for pizza at my moms nursing home nearby. Had a large deluxe and a chef salad for her and family of four visiting. Really a nice pizza and staff helpful. Chef salad was huge, so full in the container we could not shake up w dressing or even pick stuff out for plates. Great and fresh though. Definitely a keeper.

Great pizza but terrible customer service. Ordered and paid for a 4 topping pizza but only received 3 items. didn't notice till got home so ate it. ordered same pizza the following week and they wouldn't give me a 4 topping pizza for the price of 3 topping which seems fair to me. miss the pizza but won't be back until the policy is fixed and common sense prevails

Angelina's catered the OFHS 50th year reunion for the class of '72. It was held at Olmsted Township Community Room. Judy of Angelina's did a great job serving the food and helping with cleanup. Everyone had a wonderful time and the food was perfect.

We ordered Angelina's for a baby shower and it was so perfect. Food was delivered on time and hot.
The pizza is so classic and exactly what you want in a pizza- flavorful sauce, with the right balance of cheese and toppings to dough. Everyone commented on how delicious the pizza was

The crust is what you come for, whether it is the calzone, pepperoni roll or pizza! The only reason I gave it four stars is that they are a little chintzy on the toppings. Ordered a small, six slice pizza with sausage and pepperoni and there were exactly six pieces of sausage and maybe ten slices of pepperoni. Wish I had taken a pic, but the smell of hot pizza overwhelm me and I was eating it before I even thought about taking a pic.

It was very nice to go and order pizza by the slice. We went on a lunch hour and they hardly had any pizza made to chose from. At that time around 6 square sections. I was able to try the pepperoni and my hubby had the veggie. The pizza wasn't bad. There were people picking up pizza and placing orders, so they must have a following. The place inside is simple, you can sit and eat inside. I was just left feeling underwhelmed. I will definitely go again at a different time of the day. I need to give them the benefit of the doubt. They seemed dedicated and hard working, so kudos to them. They are conveniently located next to Drug Mart. I did see a beauty salon. I did see a Chinese restaurant as well. Hopefully I can get to try other places around the area.

$10 for a small one topping mediocre at best pizza is a bit much. $6-$8 would be more like it. Nothing too special about this pizza joint. Stopped for a quick to go order while out and about on the run. The guy who took my order didn't even ask for a name so when I came back in to pick it up the girl who took care of me had no idea. Then she asked me "is it pick up or to go?" Last I checked weren't the two pretty much the same in the food industry?!?! Needless to say I won't be coming back and I wouldn't recommend.