Cassano's Pizza & Subs

I'm going to be very upfront about this review. I am partial to Cassano's and may not be completely unbiased. That said.

I love this place! The server was super nice and took great care of us during our lunch meeting.

The food was of course awesome. Who doesn't love a great sausage and pepperoni pizza on a wonderful thin crust. The salad was actually a surprise, but it shouldn't have been because everything here is great.

Now, I'm not from Sidney so this is the part that I really love about this location. All the hometown pictures on the wall and cozy feel just make you feel good.

Stop by here if you are in the area. It's a wonderful little pizza place. Why we don't have them in Cincinnati is a complete mystery to me. Next time I talk to the owners I will ask them.

best pizza I have ever had good breadsticks good cheese and pizza sauce good potato skins all around great. Great service

Best pizza ever!!!
I use to live in Sidney Ohio but moved to Georgia when I was young and every time we come to visit we have to have Cassanos.
I wish they would open one in Georgia

Great food, good service at a great value! Hope the menu pics help some folks realize this is a great spot for a few beers and a pizza!

Driving up from Cinci to Michigan, we stopped into this Pizza joint for lunch. We asked the server how the wings were, and she told us they were quite popular, so me and my buddy ended up ordering that with some breadsticks. The breadsticks came out first steaming, but they ended up being doughy in the middle... then the wings came out... they are the worst wings I've ever had, completely flavorless and disgusting. We asked for hot sauce and all they had was mild verde cholula. The sauce made the wings worse. My buddy and I could stomach only 3.5 wings each out of the two dozen we got (we can put down wings btw). Then we got our bill and the wings were not priced as advertised on the menu. The pizza here might be good, but the wings are not, and good pizza joints should make good wings. At least the dogs will be happy when we bring back the hefty amount of leftovers. The server was nice though, and could see our disappointment.

This is my favorite pizza in Sidney. We typically get carry out as the seating is a bit small.

Always delicious food and the prices are reasonable for a high quality pizza. We order for pickup since they don't deliver to our area. Our order is always ready on time and is hot and fresh

Great locally owned business. Reasonably priced. Well staffed. Good food. I would recommend to anyone.

If you are familiar with Cassano's Pizza King, this is not one. That's really odd since it has the same logo. But, their staff will tell you, they are independently owned. And apparently not like a franchise.

Cassano's Pizza King does not list this location. Sure, they make pizza, but it became apparent as we tried to order from the www.cassanos.com website, they don't have the same menu. You cannot order online. Call the restaurant and they will tell you, they don't have a website or internet menu. "Come in and we'll give you a to go menu." So no specials that the other restaurants have, no toasted raviolis, no Big 60. Oddly no breadsticks, at least not resembling breadsticks... more like Pillsbury crescent rolls that weren't allowed to rise. So no Pepperoni Stuffed Sticks, no Jalapeño Stuffed Sticks. No tater babies.

The pizza we ordered was okay. A decent Ohio pepperoni pizza, square cut, thin crust. But not the Cassano's we know from the Dayton-Springfield area. This is more like a "Coming to America'" McDowell's when you were expecting McDonald's!

If you are from Sidney, you might know this and it's okay. But if you go there expecting Vic Cassano's, be prepared.

have been coming here for years. GOOOD Fooood!!! good value too!
lots of sports teams come in after games, it is always busy! Love the vibrant atmosphere!